On March 13, a dozen expert and consumer judges met in Beijing for the Grape Wall Challenge and tasted 23 red wines that retail for less than RMB100 in China (see gallery). The experts rated each out of 20 points, while the consumers had four choices – “love it“, “like it“, “dislike it” or “hate it“. The wines were from France (6), Chile (5), Argentina (4), South Africa (3), Australia (2), the United States (1), Spain (1), and Italy (1). Cedar Creek Shiraz (Australia), distributed by Top Cellar, took top honors.
Here are “top tens” of the expert panel, the consumer panel, and the combined panel.
–
EXPERT PANEL: Top 10 Red Wines
1
Cedar Creek (Shiraz, Cabernet Sauvignon) 2008, Australia / Top Cellar, RMB92
2
Callia Alta (Shiraz, Malbec) 2007, Argentina / Torres, RMB72
3
Santa Carolina (Cabernet Sauvignon) 2007, Chile / Aussino, RMB98
4
Las Condes (Cabernet Sauvignon) 2008, Chile / EMW, RMB86
5 (tie)
Leopard’s Leap: The Lookout (Cabernet Sauvignon, Shiraz, Cinsault) 2006, South Africa / Aussino, RMB95
Concha y Toro Frontera (Cabernet Sauvignon) 2008, Chile / Summergate, RMB79
7
Michel Torino (Malbec) 2007, Argentina / Palette, RMB98
8
Domaine du Landeyran AOC St. Chinian (Grenache, Syrah) 2005, France / BJ Winestore, RMB85
9
Foot of Africa (Pinotage) 2006, South Africa / Torres, RMB99
Catena “Retamo” (Bonarda, Malbec) 2007, Argentina / Summergate, RMB89
–
CONSUMER PANEL: Top 10 Red Wines
1
Foot of Africa (Pinotage) 2006, South Africa / Torres, RMB99
Paso del Sol (Merlot) 2007, Chile / DT Asia, RMB95
3 (tie)
Callia Alta (Shiraz, Malbec) 2007, Argentina / Torres, RMB72
4 (tie)
Trapiche (Pinot Noir) 2007, Argentina / Links, RMB95
Domaine du Landeyran AOC St.Chinian (Grenache, Syrah) 2005, France / BJ Winestore, RMB85
Senorio de Alange (Tempranillo) 2005, Spain / Palette, RMB79
Concha y Toro Frontera (Cabernet Sauvignon) 2008, Chile / Summergate, RMB79
Cedar Creek (Shiraz, Cabernet Sauvignon) 2008, Australia / Top Cellar, RMB92
Michel Torino (Malbec) 2007, Argentina / Palette, RMB98
10 (tie)
Rutherglen Estate Big Red (Shiraz Durif) 2006, Australia / Gelipu, RMB89
Domaine de Sarret (Cabernet Franc, Merlot, Syrah), non-vintage, France / DCT, RMB83
Santa Carolina (Cabernet Sauvignon) 2007, Chile / Aussino, RMB98
Chateau St. Pierre (Cabernet Sauvignon) 2007, United States / ASC, RMB74
Catena “Retamo” (Bonarda, Malbec) 2007, Argentina / Summergate, RMB89
Leopard’s Leap: The Lookout (Cabernet Sauvignon, Shiraz, Cinsault) 2006, South Africa / Aussino, RMB95
–
COMBINED PANELS: Overall Top Ten Red Wines
1
Cedar Creek (Shiraz, Cabernet Sauvignon) 2008, Australia / Top Cellar, RMB92
2
Callia Alta (Shiraz, Malbec) 2007, Argentina / Torres, RMB72
3
Foot of Africa (Pinotage) 2006, South Africa / Torres, RMB99
4
Paso del Sol (Merlot) 2007, Chile / DT Asia, RMB95
5
Concha y Toro Frontera (Cabernet Sauvignon) 2008, Chile / Summergate, RMB79
6
Michel Torino (Malbec) 2007, Argentina / Palette, RMB98
7
Domaine du Landeyran AOC St.Chinian (Grenache, Syrah) 2005, France / BJ Winestore, RMB85
8
Santa Carolina (Cabernet Sauvignon) 2007, Chile / Aussino, RMB98
9
Senorio de Alange (Tempranillo) 2005, Spain / Palette, RMB79
10
Leopard’s Leap: The Lookout (Cabernet Sauvignon, Shiraz, Cinsault) 2006, South Africa / Aussino, RMB95
–
See also:
- Grape Wall Challenge: Top white wines in China under RMB100
- Grape Wall Challenge: Top red wines in China under RMB100
- Grape Wall Challenge: Expert panel
- Grape Wall Challenge: Consumer panel – white wine
- Grape Wall Challenge: Consumer panel – red wines
- Grape Wall Challenge: Photo gallery
- Grape Wall Challenge: List of posts
Sign up for the Grape Wall newsletter here. Follow Grape Wall on LinkedIn, Instagram, Facebook and Twitter. And see my sibling sites World Marselan Day, World Baijiu Day and Beijing Boyce. Grape Wall has no advertisers, so if you find the content useful, please help cover the costs via PayPal, WeChat or Alipay. Contact Grape Wall via grapewallofchina (at) gmail.com.
Thanks for this list. I’ll take it with me next time to China. While in Beijing last February I could not find wine by Grace Vineyard. May be I did not look hard enough. But it also says that it is not readily available to the average Chinese wine drinker. I wait eagerly for tasting results of Chinese wine.
@ Ryan,
Re: “…. not one Chinese wine could be found worthy of a less-than-100RMB challenge? Is this a statement on Chinese wine, or a statement on having to pay well for Chinese wine worth drinking?”
None of the above: We asked importers to submit wines and rare is the company with a Chinese brand in its portfolio (Torres, with Grace Vineyard, ranks among the exceptions). Thus, no surprise that we didn’t have any Chinese wine. In any case, we plan to hold a second challenge, focused on Chinese boutique wines, in a few months.
Cheers, Jim
If you want to try wine from a very good Chinese vineyard and producer, try the range by Grace Vineyard of Shanxi.
This includes wine at “under 100 RMB” – but also treat yourself to “Deep Blue” or one that I think is called “Chairman’s Choice”…or something like that!
I’ve spent a couple of days at the vineyard and the winery and was impressed.
No bulk wine or bulk grapes !
All wine from own controlled vineyards.
It’s gotta be said – not one Chinese wine could be found worthy of a less-than-100RMB challenge?
Is this a statement on Chinese wine, or a statement on having to pay well for Chinese wine worth drinking?
Congrats with a successful Grape Wall of China Wine Challenge and a fruitful conclusion. Was discussing with Brian Yeo and so far the comments had been very fruitful and drooling.
I trust this is going to be on an annual or regular basis going forward?
Looking forward to reading more about your wines and articles on your site.
Cheers,
Daniel
Jiuwine.com
interesting results! I’m really surprised Torres didn’t enter their Sangre de Toro in the contest. I expected that to be their “fer de lance”
Right, i’m off to buy some wines. Seems to me this is a great chance for me to taste and compare.
Thanks for organising this. It saves me the choice of having to work through the dizzying array of bottles at my local stop.