Monthly Archives: December 2021

Top 100 Chinese wines | Shuai Zekun’s 2021 list for James Suckling

Wow, critic Shuai Zekun, who reviews for James Suckling, just released some kind of top 100 Chinese wine list.

There are the expected entries, like Ao Yun by LVMH and Longdai by DBR Lafite — yawn — but also nice surprises like a Dornfelder from Petit Mont and a white from Bolongbao produced right here within Beijing city limits. The top wine by score is that Ao Yun from Yunnan while the “wine of the year” hails from Kanaan in Ningxia. I also bet this list inspires a bit of outrage, too, including from Silver Heights fanatics when they see Emma’s Reserve barely making the list at #99.

Other well-known names in the top 20 include Helan Qing Xue, known for winning that Decanter award a decade ago; Xiao Ling from Yunnan; the sibling wineries Domaine Franco Chinois and Canaan just outside Beijing in Huailai County; Chateau Sungod, also in Huailai County; and two wineries consulted on by Deng Zhongxiang, China’s breakout star of the past two years, Lansai and Rong Yuan Mei.

To be clear, Shuai’s list does have its limits. It’s based on about 300 wines in a scene that now has thousands of options. Also, there are some producers that might have made the top 100 but with wines he told me he has not yet tasted–an example would be Chateau Hedong. And wineries are capped at three entries in the top 100.

“We have ranked this list of Top 100 Wines from China after weighing in on quality, the ‘wow’ factor, value, availability and consistency, and no more than three wines were selected from each producer,” he writes.

But as a long-time consumer of Chinese wine, I’m happy to see many of my favorite wines listed, even if I don’t agree with every pick or the order. This is a valuable list for those getting started with Chinese wines.

I also have to add that I’ve met Shuai a half-dozen times the past year, at trade fairs and tastings and restaurants, and he’s always been down to earth and open with sharing his opinions. Frankly, I find the focus on wine education, scores and contest medals–on appeals to authority–to have been excessive this past decade, especially given how the wine market has stagnated and struggled. But they are a reality and Shuai seems the kind of person who can best straddle the bridge between producers and consumers.

I’ve got a bunch of work to do, so this is just a quick post, and I’ll write more about this list later. Shuai Zekun’s list is currently available for free at this link.

Ningxia Q&8 | Wang Fang on Kanaan Riesling, dogs vs horses & her new winery

Wang Fang returned to her home region of Ningxia from Germany about a dozen years ago and founded the winery Kanaan, now among China’s best-known operations. In this Q&8, she discusses her wine, including Riesling, the 2021 vintage, dogs versus horses, the German foods she misses most and her new and bigger wine project.

1 Kanaan is especially famous for Riesling. What makes Ningxia Riesling unique?

One reason Kanaan Riesling became popular is the grape is relatively rare in China. In a desert-like environment like Ningxia, it’s really difficult to plant Riesling compared to a grape like Chardonnay.

The challenges are to keep the fruit healthy–to protect it from disease–especially as we can get heavy rain in August just before harvest. And to watch our harvest time very carefully because the sugar levels can rapidly rise. The alcohol content is higher compared to some other parts the world.

But you also get surprises from my Riesling. The clay soil gives a clean aroma, with tropical fruits, some lemon, banana and yellow pear, and, after bottle aging, minerality. That’s really surprising. Also, Ningxia has many kinds of terroir–my soil is quite different from that in the Jin Shan [Gold Mountain] area, for example.

2 Your father Wang Fengyu is well-known in Ningxia’s wine industry. What role has he played at Kanaan?

My father is more or less a founder, a pioneer, of Ningxia’s fine wine industry. He guided me from Germany to China and helped me build up this winery. He is always watching and offering advice, always positive and encouraging, and says to not fear difficulties because all of them can be overcome.

3 You lived in Germany for a long time. What three foods do you miss most?

Oh, I love your third question. Cheese, lovely cheese. German black bread, Schwarzbrot. And Spargel [white asparagus soup]. And, of course, Riesling to drink.

4 Kanaan’s labels feature horses but visitors will also find many dogs at the winery. Why so many?

I think dogs have also become an image for Kanaan because not only me, but the whole staff, loves them. I lost two dogs two weeks ago, so I think we now have about 15 in total.

I got some dogs from friends but most were abandoned, given up by their owners. If someone says they cannot feed their dog anymore, I would also like to take it to my vineyard. And sometimes I find puppies or sick dogs when I am walking on our property, and I bring them back.

Our winery is like a kindergarten, like a big family of dogs and people.

5 This was a challenging vintage in Ningxia. How did things go at Kanaan?

This is a challenging vintage but a very good one, although I lost nearly 50 percent of my Chardonnay last winter [due to the weather] and had to buy some this year to make my semi-sweet white wine.

For the reds, it’s much better than last vintage. The color is a deep blood red and the body is rich but not too fat. Sometimes we get big fat wines and I’m not satisfied but this year is more concentrated and leaner. When I taste our top wine this year, I think, “Oh, this reminds me of Napa Valley.”

I also made 5,000 bottles of Syrah. You must taste the Syrah, it is really surprising.

6 Many people got to know Kanaan due to the Pretty Pony Cabernet-blend. What are your three favorite dishes with this wine?

Pretty Pony is our flagship wine. It perfectly matches the Cantonese dish, crispy pork belly. Also, beef and yangrou chuanr [mutton kebabs] go very well.

7 It seems more people are visiting Ningxia wineries these past two years. What was your experience?

Yes, we had more visitors come and taste the wine, not only trade people but also wine lovers. They love to talk with us and see the winery and vineyard firsthand. This is the best way to promote Ningxia and Ningxia wines.

The problem is my winery is a family operation. We don’t have someone to handle reception and welcome guests, so my husband and I always play tour guide.

If people make an appointment, we can organize a very good tour. But tourism is the way to go, we should welcome more guests to Ningxia.

8 What do you like to do in your free time?

If I had more free time, I would like to visit wonderful restaurants, to try really good wines from all over the world. This makes me happiest. I love traveling, I love good food, I love good wine.

I also want to learn more about digital media, marketing and sales, about platforms like Douyin, and about video. The world is changing quickly and if we want to reach younger consumers, to talk to young people, we need to learn more about their lifestyles.

Bonus. What can you tell us about your new winery, Mulando, which aims to be a bigger domestic brand than Kanaan?

I like to talk to people and see what they think is fine wine and what is going to become popular. Of course, we have to produce good quality wine, but we have to focus on our consumers and what they want and love to drink.

Mulando is a new type of winery, with the shareholders including e-commerce and education platform Vinehoo, and is totally different from Kanaan. Both produce good quality wine but the consumers each ones target and the channels we use to promote are quite different.

[This post also appears on social media accounts promoting Ningxia wine. Get updates about the Ningxia’s wine scene via InstagramFacebook and Twitter. And read more Q&8s here.]